Distinguishing data controllers from data processors

Pandectes GDPR Compliance app for Shopify Stores - Distinguishing data controllers from data processors - Cover

Table of Contents


In the world of data protection, it is important to understand the differences between data controllers and data processors clearly. Data controllers are typically responsible for determining the purposes and means of processing personal data, while data processors are responsible for carrying out the actual processing on behalf of the data controller. It is important to note that both roles are crucial in processing personal data, and delineating their responsibilities is essential for compliance with data protection laws, particularly with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union. The GDPR places significant obligations on data controllers and data processors, including transparency, data security, and accountability requirements. By understanding the nuances of these roles and their obligations, organizations can take steps to ensure that they are meeting their responsibilities under data protection laws.

Definition of the data controller

A data controller is a legal or physical entity responsible for determining the reasons, methods, and processes of collecting, processing, and storing personal data. In simpler words, they are the ones who decide why and how personal data is being handled. The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) highlights the crucial role of the data controller in ensuring that the processing of personal data is conducted lawfully and fairly. Data controllers must ensure that they comply with the GDPR’s requirements and protect the rights of data subjects. They must also ensure that they only collect data that is necessary and relevant for the purpose of processing and that they keep it secure and confidential.

Definition of the data processor

In the context of data protection, a data controller is an organization that determines the purpose and means of processing personal data. On the other hand, a data processor is an entity that processes personal data on behalf of the data controller. The processor is responsible for executing the actual data processing activities, but only under the explicit instructions of the data controller. This includes tasks such as collecting, recording, organizing, structuring, storing, altering, retrieving, using, disclosing, erasing, or destroying personal data. The data processor should act strictly within the scope of their instructions and not use the data for any other purposes. Additionally, the data controller is ultimately responsible for ensuring that the processor complies with data protection regulations and that proper contractual safeguards are in place between the two parties.

Pandectes GDPR Compliance app for Shopify Stores - Distinguishing data controllers from data processors - Pointer

The key role of data controllers

As per data protection laws, data controllers are responsible for ensuring compliance. It’s their obligation to demonstrate compliance and establish a lawful basis for processing personal data. GDPR guidelines lay emphasis on controllers implementing appropriate security measures and safeguards to protect the data subjects. These measures could include physical and technical security arrangements, access controls, encryption, and pseudonymization. Controllers must ensure that the processing activities are transparent and fair and that data subjects are aware of their rights with respect to their personal data. Additionally, they must ensure that the data is accurate, up-to-date, and not kept longer than necessary.

The key role of data processors

When it comes to processing personal data, data processors have a clear obligation to carry out their duties only in accordance with the instructions provided by the data controller. These professionals are tasked with executing the technical aspects of data processing and play a vital role in ensuring that all guidelines set forth by the controller are strictly adhered to. This means that they are responsible for taking all necessary measures to safeguard the privacy and security of personal data while also ensuring that all processing activities are carried out in a transparent and ethical manner. By working closely with data controllers, data processors help ensure that personal data is managed in a way that is fully compliant with all applicable laws and regulations, while also minimizing any potential risks or vulnerabilities.

The main difference: Decision-making authority

The differentiation between a data controller and a data processor centers around the decision-making authority. A data controller is responsible for determining the purpose and manner in which personal data is processed, while a data processor follows the instructions provided by the controller. This dichotomy is critical in ensuring accountability and adherence to legal obligations in relation to data protection. By assigning distinct roles to the controller and processor, it becomes clear who is responsible for what aspects of data processing, and this clarity helps to ensure that personal data is handled in accordance with the applicable laws and regulations.

Data controllers have the responsibility of establishing a lawful basis for processing personal data. The lawful basis could be obtained through consent, contractual necessity, legal obligations, vital interests, public tasks, or legitimate interests. The choice of the lawful basis must be based on the specific circumstances surrounding the processing of personal data. For instance, data controllers may obtain consent from the data subjects before processing their data. Alternatively, they may process the data when it’s necessary for the performance of a contract or to comply with legal obligations. In situations where there is a threat to the data subject’s life, vital interests may serve as the lawful basis for processing personal data. Additionally, data controllers may process personal data for public tasks or when it’s necessary for their legitimate interests. The selection of a lawful basis for data processing ensures that data controllers operate transparently and lawfully when handling personal data.

Pandectes GDPR Compliance app for Shopify Stores - Distinguishing data controllers from data processors - Caution

Dual roles: When a company acts as both

It is common for some entities to find themselves performing dual roles as both a data controller and a data processor, depending on the context. For instance, a company may collect personal data directly from customers, thereby assuming the role of a data controller. At the same time, the company may engage a third-party service provider to carry out specific data processing activities, thus assuming the role of a data processor. This means that the company would be responsible for ensuring that the personal data collected from customers is processed legally, fairly, and transparently while also ensuring that the third-party service provider processes the data securely and complies with applicable data protection laws.

Data processing agreements

When data controllers engage data processors’ services, a data processing agreement (DPA) becomes necessary to formalize the relationship between both parties. This legal document spells out the terms and conditions governing the processing activities and ensures that the processor operates within the confines of the controller’s instructions. It outlines the data types that the processor would handle, how the data would be processed and stored securely, the duration of the processing, and the procedures for handling data breaches. Additionally, the DPA outlines the rights and obligations of both parties, including the processor’s duty to assist the controller in meeting its regulatory obligations and how to terminate the agreement. Overall, the DPA is a crucial tool that helps ensure that data processing activities are carried out compliant and transparently.

Security measures in data processing

As data privacy concerns continue growing, implementing appropriate security measures has become more critical than ever for data controllers and processors. In order to protect sensitive personal data against potential security breaches, it is essential to have a comprehensive security framework in place, which includes access controls, encryption, and regular security assessments. Access controls help ensure that only authorized personnel can view and manipulate sensitive data, while encryption ensures that data is protected both in transit and at rest. Regular assessments are also important to identify potential vulnerabilities and address them proactively before any security incidents occur. By implementing these security measures, organizations can help to safeguard personal data and protect against unauthorized access and data breaches.

Data breaches and responsibilities

In the unfortunate event of a data breach, it’s crucial to understand the distinct responsibilities that data controllers and processors have. The controller, who is ultimately responsible for determining the purposes and means of the data processing, must notify the relevant supervisory authority and data subjects in case of a breach. On the other hand, the processor, who processes personal data on behalf of the controller, must inform the controller without undue delay. This collaborative approach ensures that all parties are informed in a timely manner, which is crucial in mitigating the impact of data breaches. By working together, controllers and processors can take swift action to contain the breach, minimize any damage, and prevent future breaches.

Pandectes GDPR Compliance app for Shopify Stores - Distinguishing data controllers from data processors - Agreement

Joint controllership

In specific situations, when several entities collaborate to establish the reasons and methods for processing personal data, they may become joint controllers. This joint controllership requires a well-defined allocation of responsibilities and effective cooperation among parties to ensure compliance with data protection laws. A clear delineation of data processing roles and obligations is critical to avoid confusion and potential disputes between joint controllers. Additionally, joint controllers must establish transparent communication channels and appropriate mechanisms to guarantee data subject rights, such as access, rectification, erasure, or objection.

Sub-processors and third-party involvement

Data processors may sometimes engage sub-processors to perform certain tasks as part of their data processing activities. It is the responsibility of the main processor to ensure that these sub-processors comply with the same level of data protection that was agreed upon with the data controller. This includes ensuring that sub-processors have appropriate security measures in place to protect the data they handle, that they do not use the data for any purpose other than the task assigned to them, and that they delete the data once the task is completed. Additionally, the main processor should ensure that sub-processors are transparent about their own sub-processors, if any, and that data subjects are adequately informed about any changes in sub-processors.

Processing on behalf of a public authority

When processing personal data on behalf of a public authority, the organization or entity acting as a processor is responsible for ensuring compliance with specific legal obligations. This includes understanding the context in which personal data is processed, such as the purpose of the data processing, the type of data being processed, and the legal basis for processing the data. It is also important to consider the rights of the data subjects and ensure that appropriate technical and organizational measures are in place to protect their personal data from unauthorized access, disclosure, alteration, or destruction. Failure to comply with these legal obligations can lead to significant penalties and reputational damage for the processor and harm to the individuals whose data is being processed. Therefore, it is crucial for organizations to take a proactive approach to compliance and prioritize data protection in all aspects of their operations.


In order to ensure compliance with data protection laws, it is crucial to distinguish between the roles of data controllers and data processors. Data controllers are responsible for determining the purposes and means of processing personal data, while data processors are responsible for processing personal data on behalf of the controller. Both parties have legal obligations to adhere to in order to safeguard the rights and interests of data subjects. This includes ensuring clarity in roles and responsibilities, maintaining a commitment to privacy, and implementing robust security measures to protect personal data in an increasingly data-driven world. By carefully defining and adhering to these roles and obligations, organizations can establish a solid framework for processing personal data that is compliant with data protection laws.

Make your Shopify Store GDPR/CCPA compliant today
Pandectes GDPR Compliance App for Shopify
Subscribe to learn more

You Might Also Like

Scroll to Top