Introduction
The American Privacy Rights Act (APRA) was a bipartisan proposal for a comprehensive federal data privacy law in the United States. It would have defined “covered data” and “sensitive covered data”, required businesses to collect only the data they actually need, given consumers a set of privacy rights, and been enforced by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), state attorneys general and, in some cases, consumers themselves.
The bill would also have replaced most state privacy laws, such as the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), with one national standard, while keeping some state laws in place. It included extra duties for large data holders, a registry for data brokers, and limits on targeted advertising.
Supporters saw it as a way to close the gaps between state privacy laws and to bring the U.S. closer to global standards like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). This article explains what APRA would have done, and what it means for businesses today.
Status: APRA never became law. It was released as a discussion draft in April 2024 and introduced in the House as H.R. 8818 on June 25, 2024. The House Energy and Commerce Committee cancelled its full-committee markup of the bill on June 27, 2024, and the bill died when the 118th Congress ended in January 2025. In April 2026, House Republicans introduced a different federal privacy bill, the SECURE Data Act (H.R. 8413). It is also only a proposal. The United States still has no comprehensive federal privacy law.
Covered data and sensitive covered data
APRA would have defined “covered data” as information that identifies a person or is reasonably linkable to one, such as contact details, purchase history or device identifiers. Employee information and de-identified data were left out of this definition.
“Sensitive covered data” was a narrower group of categories that would have received stronger protection. It included health information, biometric and genetic data, precise geolocation, financial account details, information about sexual behavior and the content of private communications. The June 2024 version added neural data and information revealing membership in the Armed Forces. The difference between the two categories mattered, because most of the bill’s consent rules applied only to sensitive covered data.
Federal Trade Commission’s role
The FTC would have been the main federal enforcer. It could have treated violations of APRA as unfair or deceptive practices and sought civil penalties, injunctions and other relief. The bill would also have directed the FTC to set up a new bureau for privacy enforcement and created a fund to pay penalty money to people affected by violations.
The FTC would not have acted alone. State attorneys general and state privacy authorities could also have sued businesses on behalf of their residents.
Data minimization and security practices
Data minimization was at the center of APRA. A business could only have collected, processed, retained or transferred covered data when it was reasonably necessary and proportionate to provide a product or service the person asked for, to send a communication the person would reasonably expect, or for one of a list of other permitted purposes (such as security, fraud prevention or legal compliance). Stricter limits applied to sensitive, biometric and genetic data.
The bill would also have required reasonable data security practices and asked covered entities to designate one or more qualified employees as privacy or data security officers, responsible for running the privacy and security programs and overseeing compliance.

Impact on large data holders and small businesses
APRA would have applied to most businesses and nonprofits that handle covered data, but it treated organizations differently by size.
Large data holders, meaning companies with very high revenue that process data on millions of people, would have faced extra duties. For example, they would have had to answer consumer rights requests faster (within 15 days, compared with 30 days for other covered entities).
Small businesses, on the other hand, would have been exempt rather than given lighter rules. Under the bill, a business generally counted as small if it had about $40 million or less in average annual revenue, did not handle the covered data of more than 200,000 people a year, and did not earn money by transferring covered data to third parties. A small business acting as a service provider for a covered entity could still have been subject to the bill in that role. Because exempt small businesses would not have been “covered entities”, some commentators noted they might still have had to follow state privacy laws.
Transferring covered data
APRA did not require consent for every data transfer. Instead, it set two levels:
- Sensitive covered data: a business would have needed the person’s affirmative express consent before transferring it to a third party. Express consent was also required before collecting, processing or retaining biometric or genetic information.
- Other covered data: transfers would have been allowed, but people could have opted out of them, and of the use of their data for targeted advertising.
This approach is close to how most U.S. state privacy laws work today: opt-in for sensitive data, opt-out for most other uses.
Comparisons with existing state privacy laws
APRA would have created a single federal framework for consumer privacy. Here is how it compared with the state privacy laws that apply today:
-
Scope and preemption:
-
APRA: Would have applied nationwide and expressly preempted most state privacy laws. Some state laws would have survived, including general consumer protection laws, employee privacy laws and health privacy laws.
-
State Laws, such as the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and Virginia Consumer Data Protection Act (VCDPA), vary in scope and requirements, which creates a patchwork of rules.
-
-
Consumer rights:
-
APRA: Would have given people the right to access, correct, delete and export their covered data, and to opt out of targeted advertising and data transfers.
-
State Laws: Most comprehensive state laws offer similar rights, with variations. For example, the CCPA focuses on the right to opt out of the sale and sharing of personal information, and the VCDPA includes rights to correction and data portability.
-
-
Enforcement and penalties:
-
APRA: Would have been enforced by the FTC, state attorneys general and state privacy authorities, plus a private right of action for certain violations.
-
State Laws: Enforcement usually lies with state attorneys general. California also allows private lawsuits for certain data breaches.
-
-
Business obligations:
-
APRA: Would have required data minimization, data security programs, privacy or data security officers and clear privacy notices.
-
State Laws: Similar obligations exist, but the details vary. For example, the Colorado Privacy Act (CPA) requires data protection assessments for high-risk processing activities.
-
-
Exemptions and exceptions:
-
APRA: Would have exempted small businesses and excluded employee data and de-identified data from covered data.
-
State Laws: Exemptions also vary by state. For instance, the Utah Consumer Privacy Act (UCPA) has revenue and volume thresholds that keep smaller businesses out of scope.
-
Because APRA did not pass, these state laws remain the rules businesses must follow.
Private right of action and consumer rights
One of APRA’s most debated features was a private right of action. Individuals could have sued businesses for certain violations, such as misuse of sensitive, biometric or genetic data, and for data breaches. In most cases, the person would first have had to notify the business and give it a chance to fix the problem, unless the violation caused substantial privacy harm. Concerns among some committee Republicans about this provision were reported as one of the obstacles before the June 2024 markup was cancelled.
The bill also listed core consumer rights: to access their covered data, correct it, delete it, export it, and opt out of targeted advertising and transfers of their data.

Data security officers and their responsibilities
Under APRA, covered entities and service providers would have had to designate one or more qualified employees as privacy or data security officers. These officers would have been responsible for implementing the organization’s data privacy and data security programs and for overseeing ongoing compliance with the bill. Even without a federal law, naming a clear owner for privacy and security is a good practice for protecting consumer data.
Employee data and privacy
APRA would not have regulated employee data. Its definition of covered data excluded employee information, such as job applications, payroll and benefits records. At the same time, the bill would have preserved state laws that protect employee privacy, so those state rules would still have applied. In practice, California’s CCPA remains the main comprehensive state privacy law that covers employee data.
Litigation costs and compliance
Compliance with APRA would have required real investment in data security, legal review, privacy impact assessments and staff training. The private right of action raised concerns about litigation costs, especially among business groups. The notice and cure step for most claims was meant to reduce lawsuits by giving businesses a chance to fix problems first. Supporters also argued that a single national standard would lower compliance costs compared with following many different state laws.
Data brokers and targeted advertising
APRA would have regulated data brokers mainly through transparency. Data brokers would have had to register with the FTC, which would have kept a public registry. The registry would have included a “Do Not Collect” mechanism that let people ask all registered data brokers to stop collecting their data. Data brokers would also have needed a public website linking to the registry.
For targeted advertising, the bill used an opt-out model: people could have opted out of having their covered data used for targeted ads. The June 2024 version added stricter limits for minors, banning targeted and first-party advertising to people a business knows are minors, with limited exceptions.

De-identified data and anonymization
APRA would have excluded de-identified data from covered data. De-identified data is information that cannot reasonably be linked to a specific person. To rely on this exclusion, a business would have had to take reasonable technical measures to prevent re-identification, publicly commit not to re-identify the data, and require anyone it shares the data with to make the same commitment. The aim was to let businesses use data for analysis while keeping individuals protected.
Impact on private communications and human decision-making
APRA treated the content of private communications, such as emails, text messages and calls, as sensitive covered data. That would have meant stronger protection, including affirmative express consent before such data could be transferred to third parties.
The April 2024 discussion draft also included a section on civil rights and algorithms. It would have banned discriminatory use of covered data, required large data holders to assess certain algorithms for risks, and let people opt out of the use of algorithms for consequential decisions about them. These algorithm and civil rights provisions were removed from the June 2024 version (H.R. 8818). So the bill as introduced did not contain them.
For decisions made by automated systems about individuals, the rules that apply today come from state laws, several of which give consumers the right to opt out of certain profiling.
Conclusion
The American Privacy Rights Act was one of the most serious attempts so far to create a comprehensive federal privacy law in the United States. It would have combined data minimization, national consumer rights, a data broker registry and broad preemption of state laws. But it never passed, and the newer SECURE Data Act is still only a proposal.
For Shopify merchants and other online businesses, the practical point is simple: there is no federal privacy law to replace the state rules. Comprehensive privacy laws in California, Virginia, Colorado and a growing list of other states apply right now. Most of them follow the pattern APRA would have used: opt-in consent for sensitive data, opt-out of targeted advertising and data sales, and rights to access and delete personal data. Building your store’s privacy practices around these state requirements is the safest approach, whatever Congress does next.


